An over-enthusiastic Muslim going by the name of “loveProphet,” who appears to be a regular at Sunni Answers, has argued that human evolution is “scientifically wrong”. He says the following:
“The comment that the proof for human evolution is irrefutable shows absolute ignorance of science. Scientific “facts” change so many times and scientific theories do too.
I’ve personally been studying the topic of evolution specifically for more than a year and although i’m not going to be bothered into going over it here, its actually plain that its nowhere close to facts like gravity nor is it irrefutable but rather i even deem human evolution scientifically wrong(and other agnostic biologists have too).
I’ve known quite a few well qualified biologists who don’t believe in it(one having a PhD). Its a theory that is a “house of cards”.
In fact i’d say that there’s scientific evidence for the Islamic account of the appearance of humans.
Note also how much distortion and lies that the evolutionists have done on the topic as atheists don’t believe they’re accountable except if they’re found out. Is it ok according to atheists to lie and misrepresent others’ beliefs?
I don’t see any point in discussing with an atheist/agnostic who is not even open to considering the other side who even resorts to mockery and ad hominem attacks.
You’ve basically ruled out the possibility of Islam being correct without any proof at the start and then based your arguments on this premise and then said about its beliefs ‘its absurd and wrong,’”
I tried responding to this curious comment, but for some strange reason, my own comments weren’t posted. I’ve therefore reproduced my comment below.
…..
Well, in that case, I’d say you’ve made things very easy for all of us, indeed.
If you believe that the thesis of evolution is wrong — that is, the thesis that biological life evolves from one species to another through a natural process or mechanism of change — then, I warmly invite you to substantiate that belief. If it really is “actually plain” that the thesis of evolution is “nowhere close to facts like gravity nor is it irrefutable,” then you should have absolutely no problem showing us why it’s wrong. The further it is from the facts, the easier it should be to refute it definitively and convincingly.
Again, I’m quite eager to have you show me why and how the scientific community is wrong and why and how you’re right
…..
UPDATE: Shaykh Abū Ādam al-Narūijī has indicated that he, too, shall soon, by the will of his god, be dealing with Darwinism. This is wonderful news! We warmly look forward to the day when he, too, will attempt to refute the scientific community and show us all why evolution is wrong and (Islamic) creationism is right.
Posted by Sign of Saturn 